Medically unexplained physical symptoms
The neutrality of this article is disputed; the specific problem is: Finish 'Articles and research in favor of lumping CFS, IBS or fibromyalgia into MUS', Controversy and general neutrality issues. (18 August 2019) (Learn how and when to remove this template message)
Medically unexplained physical symptoms (MUPS or MUS) or Persistent Physical Symptoms are symptoms for which the doctor is unable to find a cause, for example unexplained dizziness, pain without a known cause, or unexplained tiredness.
Medically unexplained symptoms may be mild, and can resolve within a few weeks without treatment, but some are more persistent. In practice, "medically unexplained" may be used to extremely broadly to describe either symptoms of a diagnosis not yet fully understood by medicine, especially ME/CFS, fibromyalgia or irritable bowel syndrome, or symptoms that are not known to be linked to a medical condition, or symptoms a medical professional judges to be out of proportion to the related physical cause or illness.
- 1 Classification and alternative names
- 2 MUS review linked to PACE trial
- 3 Somatization and psychologization
- 4 Absence of evidence of a physical cause
- 5 Forced treatment
- 6 Risk of harm in ME/CFS patients
- 7 Criticism and controversy
- 8 Costs of medically unexplained symptoms
- 9 Medical neglect
- 10 Biopsychosocial model
- 11 Patient experiences
- 12 Improving Access to Psychological Therapies
- 13 Articles and research critical of lumping ME/CFS into MUS
- 14 Articles and research in favor of lumping CFS, IBS or fibromyalgia into MUS
- 15 Notable studies and articles
- 16 Letters, talks and blogs
- 17 See also
- 18 Learn more
- 19 References
Classification and alternative names[edit | edit source]
Patients with MUS or MUPS are sometimes referred to as having Functional Somatic Symptoms (FSS) or diagnosed as Bodily Distress Syndrome (BDS) - both of which are mental illnesses - despite being classified as physical illnesses under the World Health Organization's current ICD-10 classification, and the latest ICD-11 classification. Somatoform disorders, Somatic symptom disorders, Conversion disorder, and Functional Neurological Disorder (FND) are also regarded as medically unexplained symptom and classified as purely psychological symptoms conditions only in the DSM psychiatric manual.
[edit | edit source]
In the UK there is currently a PROSPERO systematic review of medically unexplained symptoms and their treatments being undertaken by a number of authors including Peter White, first author of the controversial PACE trial for ME/CFS, into MUS.
Somatization and psychologization[edit | edit source]
A key assumption often made is that medically unexplained physical symptoms are symptoms which have no physical cause - rather than no known physical cause, and so are assumed be caused by somatization: the physical expression of emotional distress. Symptoms, or entire diagnosed illnesses such as ME/CFS or fibromyalgia, are assumed to have no underlying illness process but to have "psychosomatic" symptoms or "psychogenic illness".
The MUS approach has been used inappropriately to reclassify diagnosed physical illness, including ME/CFS, as a mental health, which can then result in inappropriate treatment, for example medical neglect, and in some severely ill patients, forced psychiatric treatment and forced exercise therapy combined with medical neglect, factors which contributed to the death of Sophia Mirza from ME/CFS.
Absence of evidence of a physical cause[edit | edit source]
Medically unexplained symptoms are often referred to as lacking evidence of any organic pathology (physical cause) - but have been criticized as overly inclusive for including patients with symptoms judged to be out of proportion to the illness or injury; this is problematic because it relies not on medical or psychological tests for MUS but on a doctor's current knowledge of a diagnosed illness or injury, and on medical science's current expectation of particularly severe cases of the each diagnosis.
A patient with a serious medical illness can find themselves also diagnosed with a "medically unexplained physical symptoms" label such as Somatic symptom disorder because of their help-seeking behavior, worry over their health or reporting a disproportionate degree of symptoms. For example, a doctor or psychiatrist assessing a person with very severe ME may be unaware that paralysis, seizures and speech problems can occur, and the illness can, in some cases, kill, so this lack of knowledge may lead to an incorrect diagnosis of MUS, with cognitive or behavioral treatments that may cause significant harm, and a denial of specialist treatment.
Forced treatment[edit | edit source]
The classification of physically ill patients as having a mental illness purely on the basis of their psychical symptoms allows for a patient to be forcibly treated if they are judged to be lacking mental capacity, something which can occur in severe ME due to be severe cognitive and concentration problems, or episodes or speech loss and paralysis that prevent communication. Despite ME patients not experiencing psychosis or other psychiatric conditions that effect judgement as part of ME, the "mentally ill" label can be, and has been, used to assume patients lack capability for treatment decisions, and to force them into harmful treatments including exercise or exercise therapies.
Historically, illnesses that were previously misunderstood or not yet identified were blamed on patients' personality, for example William Henry Day's concept of the "migraine personality" in 1878, Diamond and Dalessio (1973) claims that "up to 90% [of those with migraines] have a psychogenic basis for their complaint", patients were labeled as "untrustworthy", "drug-seeking", or as potential malingerers.Lupus, multiple sclerosis, and Lyme disease are all examples of illnesses that were previously assumed to have a psychological origin simply because of the "absence of evidence" of a physical cause.
English (2000) states that "Absence of evidence may reflect insufficient research, inadequate technology, poor methods, flawed paradigms, closed minds, or lack of clinical experience; for example, in 1980, there was no clear evidence that AIDS was viral—blood products were considered “safe.”"
Risk of harm in ME/CFS patients[edit | edit source]
|“|| Evidence-based medicine is driven by the effort to minimize medical risk. In the area of ME/CFS, however, it has long been routine for psychosomatic research to proceed as if medical risk can be ignored, as if it simply is not possible that patients with this poorly understood condition are suffering from a biomedical disease.
That oversight can no longer be maintained in credible debate and research.
—Diane O'Leary, Journal of Medical Ethics blog 2019
Criticism and controversy[edit | edit source]
The whole MUS concept of lumping different syndromes or groups of symptoms further - all of which are then regarded as "non-diseases" - has been criticized as unscientific and lacking evidence - especially with wrongly including ME, which is a recognized neurological disease. In the UK, the effect of this is that patients regarded as having MUS conditions or symptoms are treated under the Improving Access to Psychological Therapies (IAPT) programme, a mental health-only approach which does not have the facilities or skills to treat complex and severe physical health problems.
The inclusion of ME/CFS under MUS has been heavily criticized by advocates and patients with ME, especially in the UK which is obliged to follow the World Health Organization's classification system - which recognizes ME / CFS / Post-viral syndrome under neurological diseases, and excludes then from other categories.
Dr James Coyne has found that Peter White, lead author of the highly controversial PACE trial and advisor to the UK Department for Work and Pensions, did not disclose his financial interests with health insurers for the PROSPERO review.
Costs of medically unexplained symptoms[edit | edit source]
A highly influential study by Bermingham et al attempted to calculate the health care costs of patients with MUS, but incorrectly included costs of treating diseases that are not classified as MUS, including ME/CFS.
Further controversy has erupted with the repeated incorrect references to Bermingham et al. which have been published in further reviews and articles by influential journals. Dr David Tuller, a public health professional at Berkeley has repeatedly highlighted this, contacting Carolyn Chew-Graham and others who incorrectly cited the paper and the journals that published it to request corrections.
Medical neglect[edit | edit source]
Medically unexplained symptoms guidance recommendations includes avoiding doing "unnecessary" diagnostic tests due to the believe in the risk of "iatrogenic harm" and patients may be taught to avoid "symptom focusing", leaving people with a physical illness at risk of medical neglect due to the lack of investigation of comorbidities, or failure to correctly diagnose other causes for symptoms or other illnesses, and lack of biomedical treatment.
[edit | edit source]
The biopsychosocial model (BPS) is frequently used to provide treatment for medically unexplained physical symptoms. A key part of this model is the use of psychological approaches, often including a form of psychotherapy called cognitive behavioral therapy. In patients with ME/CFS, patient groups and a number of different authors, have reported that the biopsychosocial approach has led to substantial rates of harm and multiple types of harm have been identified in this patient group. A survey of over 2,000 British patients with ME/CFS was conducted in 2019 to help inform the revision of the NHS treatment guidelines, and found that the treatment was more harmful then helpful. The survey reported that more than 1 in 5 patients developed new symptoms while undergoing cognitive behavioral therapy for ME/CFS, 26% said their physical health had deteriorated as a result, with only 16% reporting improved physical health. Alarmingly, 26% found their mental health deteriorated with this psychological approach.
The psychologization of patients' illness in the absence of psychological symptoms assumes that psychological help must be needed or beneficial in patients with medically unexplained symptoms, despite the fact that an unknown number of patients may have symptoms caused by an undiagnosed medical condition, a medical condition not yet recognized by modern science, or a recognized medical condition like ME/CFS that is not fully understood yet.
Patient experiences[edit | edit source]
Patients with medically unexplained physical symptoms have described many types of negative medical encounters, including:
- harmful medical advice or treatment
- inappropriate psychological explanations) (the psychologization of symptoms)
- disbelief and disrespectful treatment from doctors and health care professionals
- marginalization of patients' experiences
- lack of physical examination and denial of tests or access to specialists that other patients receive
- failure to investigate new or worsening symptoms
- increased risk of psychiatric medications bring inappropriately prescribed
- disregarding patients' knowledge and autonomy
- the use of the MUS label to challenge the validity of patients' existing diagnosis of ME/CFS
- gender bias: female patients are more likely to be diagnosed with medically unexplained physical symptoms
Improving Access to Psychological Therapies[edit | edit source]
Improving Access to Psychological Therapies (IAPT) is the treatment arm of the MUS rollout in the UK. It has been accused of diverting millions in mental health care funding to patients without mental illness, and for its lack of effectiveness in patients with MUS.
The Journal of Health Psychology published Michael Scott's Improving Access to Psychological Therapies (IAPT) - The Need for Radical Reform, which used the PACE trial as an example of inflating rates of recovery from psychological treatments, and concluded that the IAPT similarly had little evidence to justify the treatments even for psychological conditions.
The editor of the Journal of Health Psychology, Dr David Marks, published the editorial IAPT under the microscope in July 2018, which concluded "A service based on the promise of savings by taking people off benefits is a political hot potato. There is an urgent need for an independent review of IAPT by impartial experts."
Articles and research critical of lumping ME/CFS into MUS[edit | edit source]
- 2013, The Somatic Symptom Disorder in DSM 5 risks mislabelling people with major medical diseases as mentally ill - (Full text)
- 2017, Contesting the psychiatric framing of ME/CFS(Full text)
- 2017, Absence of evidence - focusing on ME/CFS (Full text)- Margaret Williams
- 2017, Medically Unexplained Symptoms (MUS): Faults and Implications(Full text)
- 2019, Bodily Distress Syndrome: Concerns About Scientific Credibility in Research and Implementation(Full text)
Articles and research in favor of lumping CFS, IBS or fibromyalgia into MUS[edit | edit source]
- 2003, Medically unexplained symptoms: exacerbating factors in the doctor-patient encounter(Full text)
- 2004, There is only one functional somatic syndrome(Full text)
Notable studies and articles[edit | edit source]
- 2010, The cost of somatisation among the working‐age population in England for the year 2008–2009(Full text)
- 2015, Managing medically unexplained illness in general practice(Full text)
- 2017, “It´s incredible how much I´ve had to fight.” Negotiating medical uncertainty in clinical encounters(Full text)
- 2018, Nosological journey of somatoform disorders: From briquet's syndrome to bodily distress disorder(Full text)
- 2018, Why Bioethics Should Be Concerned With Medically Unexplained Symptoms(Full text)
- KNOWLEDGE IN THE HOPE OF PROTECTING M.E. SUFFERERS FROM UNNECESSARY SECTIONING - Preventing the unnecessary forced mental health sectioning of severely ill patients - The Grace Charity for M.E. with 25% ME Group
Letters, talks and blogs[edit | edit source]
- M.E. must continue to be classified as neurological - Action for ME
- 2019, It's time to pay attention to Chronic Fatigue Syndrome
- 2015, Dr Jim Bolton presents Medically Unexplained Symptoms
See also[edit | edit source]
- Cognitive behavioral therapy
- Biopsychosocial model
- David Tuller
- Ethical issues
- Stigma and discrimination
- Medical abuse and neglect
Learn more[edit | edit source]
- Absence of Evidence - Margaret Williams
- Medically unexplained symptoms - Royal College of Psychiatrists
- Trial by Error: Some thoughts on MUS and Bermingham: My letter to Professor Payne - David Tuller
- Medically unexplained symptoms - NHS
- Wikipedia - Medically unexplained physical symptoms
References[edit | edit source]
- "Medically unexplained symptoms". RC PSYCH ROYAL COLLEGE OF PSYCHIATRISTS. Retrieved Jul 10, 2019.
- "Medically unexplained symptoms". nhs.uk. Oct 19, 2017. Retrieved Jul 14, 2019.
- Smith, Robert C.; Dwamena, Francesca C. (May 1, 2007). "Classification and Diagnosis of Patients with Medically Unexplained Symptoms". Journal of General Internal Medicine. 22 (5): 685–691. doi:10.1007/s11606-006-0067-2. ISSN 1525-1497.
- Desai, Geetha; Sagar, Rajesh; Chaturvedi, Santosh K (2018). "Nosological journey of somatoform disorders: From briquet's syndrome to bodily distress disorder". Indian Journal of Social Psychiatry. 34 (5): 29–33. Retrieved Jul 15, 2019.
- Häuser, Winfried; Wolfe, Frederick (Dec 1, 2013). "The somatic symptom disorder in DSM 5 risks mislabelling people with major medical diseases as mentally ill". Journal of Psychosomatic Research. 75 (6): 586–587. doi:10.1016/j.jpsychores.2013.09.005. ISSN 0022-3999.
- Leaviss, Joanna; Glenys Parry; Stevenson, Matt; Booth, Andrew; Scope, Alison; Davis, Sarah; Ren, Shije; Sutton, Anthea; White, Peter; Moss-Morris, Rona; Buszewicz, Marta (2015). "Medically unexplained symptoms (MUS): primary care intervention. PROSPERO 2015 CRD42015025520". www.crd.york.ac.uk. Retrieved Jul 10, 2019.
- Jennie, Spotila (2013). "My feedback to the Institute of Medicine". occupyme.net. Retrieved Jul 10, 2019.
- O'Leary, Diane (Mar 5, 2019). "It's Time to Pay Attention to "Chronic Fatigue Syndrome"". Journal of Medical Ethics. Retrieved Mar 5, 2019.
- Action for ME (2017). "M.E. must continue to be classified as neurological". Action for ME. Retrieved Jul 15, 2019.
- Williams, Margaret (2017). "Absence of Evidence" (PDF).
- Spandler, Helen; Allen, Meg (Aug 16, 2017). "Contesting the psychiatric framing of ME/CFS" (PDF). Social Theory & Health. 16 (2): 127–141. doi:10.1057/s41285-017-0047-0. ISSN 1477-8211.
- Mihelicova, Martina; Siegel, Zachary; Evans, Meredyth; Brown, Abigail; Jason, Leonard (Dec 2016). "Caring for People with Severe Myalgic Encephalomyelitis: An Interpretative Phenomenological Analysis of Parents' Experiences". Journal of health psychology. 21 (12): 2824–2837. doi:10.1177/1359105315587137. ISSN 1359-1053. PMC . PMID 26063209.
- "PSYCHIATRISTS PAID BY OUTSIDE INTERESTS". www.sophiaandme.org.uk. Retrieved Jul 14, 2019.
- Geraghty, Keith J.; Blease, Charlotte (Jun 21, 2018). "Myalgic encephalomyelitis/chronic fatigue syndrome and the biopsychosocial model: a review of patient harm and distress in the medical encounter". Disability and Rehabilitation: 1–10. doi:10.1080/09638288.2018.1481149. ISSN 0963-8288.
- "Sophia and M.E." www.sophiaandme.org.uk. Retrieved Jul 15, 2019.
- Segal, Judy Z. (Apr 1, 2007). "lIlness as argumentation: a prolegomenon to the rhetorical study of contestable complaints". Health. 11 (2): 227–244. doi:10.1177/1363459307074695. ISSN 1363-4593.
- English, T. L. (Feb 15, 2000). "Functional somatic syndromes" (PDF). Annals of Internal Medicine. 132 (4): 329. ISSN 0003-4819. PMID 10681297.
- Tack, Michiel (Jan 2019). "Medically Unexplained Symptoms (MUS): Faults and Implications". International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health. 16 (7): 1247. doi:10.3390/ijerph16071247.
- O’Leary, D. (Jun 30, 2018). "Bodily distress syndrome: Concerns about scientific credibility in research and implementation". Journal of Biological Physics and Chemistry. 18 (2): 67–77t. doi:10.4024/07LE18A.jbpc.18.02.
- Scott, Michael J (Aug 1, 2018). "Improving Access to Psychological Therapies (IAPT) - The Need for Radical Reform". Journal of Health Psychology. 23 (9): 1136–1147. doi:10.1177/1359105318755264. ISSN 1359-1053.
- "MUS, PPS services and IAPT integration into NHS primary care - what's happening across the UK?". Phoenix Rising ME / CFS Forums. Retrieved Jul 10, 2019.
- The ME Association (Jul 2017). "Countess of Mar and Lord Hunt defend ME/CFS in Lords debate on medically unexplained symptoms | 05 July 2017". Retrieved Jul 10, 2019.
- Spoonseeker (Jul 29, 2018). "Probing the Holes in MUS". spoonseekerdotcom. Retrieved Jul 10, 2019.
- Marks, David F (Aug 2018). "IAPT under the microscope". Journal of Health Psychology. 23 (9): 1131–1135. doi:10.1177/1359105318781872. ISSN 1359-1053.
- "'Medically Unexplained Symptoms' - Diverting 5-Year Funding from Mental Health". www.positivehealth.com. Retrieved Jul 10, 2019.
- Coyne, James (May 1, 2016). "Undisclosed conflicts of interest in a systematic review protocol of interventions for medically unexplained symptoms (Protected Blog)". jcoynester.wordpress.com. Retrieved Jul 10, 2019.
- Spoonseeker (Jun 20, 2018). "A Morass of MUS". spoonseekerdotcom. Retrieved Jul 10, 2019.
- Bermingham, Sarah; Cohen, Alan; Hague, John; Parsonage, Michael (2010). "The cost of somatisation among the working-age population in England for the year 2008–2009". Mental Health in Family Medicine. 7 (2): 71–84. ISSN 1756-834X. PMID 22477925.
- Tuller, David (Jul 8, 2019). "Trial By Error: Some Thoughts on MUS and Bermingham; My Letter to Professor Payne". Virology blog. Retrieved Jul 14, 2019.
- Dimmock, Mary; Lazell-Fairman, Matthew (Dec 2015). "THIRTY YEARS OF DISDAIN: How HHS and a group of psychiatrists Buried Myalgic Encephalomyelitis" (PDF). Retrieved Nov 5, 2018.
- Forward-ME (2017). "10 year surveillance report consultation comments | NICE CFS/ME guidelines" (PDF). Retrieved Feb 10, 2019.
- Oxford Clinical Allied Technology and Trials Services Unit (OxCATTS) (Feb 27, 2019). "Evaluation of a survey exploring the experiences of adults and children with ME/CFS who have participated in CBT and GET interventional programmes. FINAL REPORT" (PDF). Oxford Brookes University.
- O'Leary, Diane (May 2018). "Why Bioethics Should Be Concerned With Medically Unexplained Symptoms" (PDF). The American journal of bioethics: AJOB. 18 (5): 6–15. doi:10.1080/15265161.2018.1445312. ISSN 1536-0075. PMID 29697324.
- The ME Association (Apr 2019). "Forward-ME and Oxford Brookes University announce results of patient survey on CBT and GET in ME/CFS".
- Lian, Olaug S.; Robson, Catherine (Jan 1, 2017). ""It´s incredible how much I´ve had to fight." Negotiating medical uncertainty in clinical encounters". International Journal of Qualitative Studies on Health and Well-being. 12 (1): 1392219. doi:10.1080/17482631.2017.1392219.
- The Royal Australian College of General Practitioners. "RACGP - Managing medically unexplained illness in general practice". www.racgp.org.au. Retrieved Jul 14, 2019.
- The Grace Charity for M.E.; 25% ME Group (Jan 2019). "KNOWLEDGE IN THE HOPE OF PROTECTING M.E. SUFFERERS FROM UNNECESSARY SECTIONING". Retrieved Jul 12, 2019.
Myalgic encephalomyelitis or chronic fatigue syndrome