Template talk:Cleanup

Calling from other templates
check via a page name: DMC, DMCA, Category handler, mbox?

Translation work: System messages
Translations are needed for languages: de, es, fr, nl, ar, da, fi, it, ja, no, pl, pt, ru, sv, vi, zh-hant, zh-hans
 * vi has no pagetriage messages of those needed

Done


 * Articlefeedbackv5
 * MediaWiki:Articlefeedbackv5-form-discuss-talk-exists - using MediaWiki:Cleanup-talksuggestions-desc now -
 * MediaWiki:Articlefeedbackv5-bucket4-title - using MediaWiki:Cleanup-helpimprove now -  - done


 * LiquidThreads
 * MediaWiki:Lqt_noreason - done as MediaWiki:No-reason


 * Moodbar
 * MediaWiki:Moodbar-action-reason-required - only used by Template error message - English only so far


 * Pagetriage
 * Many

Exports from translatewiki special export
ar, da, fi, it, ja, no, pl, pt, ru, sv, vi, zh-hant, zh-hans

lqt as No-reason only

mediawiki:pagetriage-tags-cleanupreorganise-desc/ar mediawiki:pagetriage-tags-condense-label/ar mediawiki:pagetriage-tags-copyedit-desc/ar mediawiki:pagetriage-tags-disputed-desc/ar mediawiki:pagetriage-tags-externallinks-desc/ar mediawiki:pagetriage-tags-nonfree-desc/ar mediawiki:pagetriage-tags-pov-desc/ar mediawiki:pagetriage-tags-refimprove-desc/ar mediawiki:/arpagetriage-tags-stub-label/ar mediawiki:pagetriage-tags-technical-desc/ar mediawiki:pagetriage-tags-unbalanced-desc/ar Mediawiki:pagetriage-tags-verylong-desc/ar

Mediawiki:Lqt_noreason| mediawiki:Mobile-frontend-photo-upload| mediawiki:Moodbar-action-reason-required| mediawiki:pagetriage-tags-citationstyle-desc| mediawiki:pagetriage-tags-cleanupreorganise-desc| mediawiki:pagetriage-tags-condense-label| mediawiki:pagetriage-tags-copyedit-desc| mediawiki:pagetriage-tags-disputed-desc| mediawiki:pagetriage-tags-externallinks-desc| mediawiki:pagetriage-tags-nonfree-desc| mediawiki:pagetriage-tags-pov-desc| mediawiki:pagetriage-tags-refimprove-desc| mediawiki:|pagetriage-tags-stub-label| mediawiki:pagetriage-tags-technical-desc| mediawiki:pagetriage-tags-unbalanced-desc| Mediawiki:pagetriage-tags-verylong-desc|

Translations done
Done many of
 * Cleanup-helpimprove
 * Cleanup-reason-is
 * Cleanup-talksuggestions-desc
 * MediaWiki:pagetriage-tags-cleanup-desc/vi needed

Many custom messages to do





Cleanup message

 * MediaWiki:pagetriage-tags-cleanup-desc - done
 * MediaWiki:Cleanup-reason-is - done
 * MediaWiki:Moodbar-action-reason-required

Citations needed - done

 * MediaWiki:pagetriage-tags-refimprove-desc
 * MediaWiki:pagetriage-tags-refimprove-desc

Text templates used - done

 * Template:Talkpage text
 * Uses MediaWiki:Cleanup-talksuggestions-desc - done

Template:Cleanup reason text

 * MediaWiki:No-reason
 * MediaWiki:Moodbar-action-reason-required
 * (After Localization update add in link for cleanup reasons? Or custom message without needing extension??)

Template:Help improve text

 * MediaWiki:Cleanup-helpimprove - based on MediaWiki:Articlefeedbackv5-bucket4-title
 * Needs more system messages, edit English to include link. Still using LangSwitch

Science guidelines not met and/or referencing issues - just started

 * MediaWiki:Guidelines-science
 * MediaWiki:Guidelines-science


 * MediaWiki:pagetriage-tags-externallinks-desc

Manual of style not met - started

 * MediaWiki:Cleanup-tags-mos-desc
 * MediaWiki:Guidelines-mos (custom message)
 * MediaWiki:pagetriage-tags-cleanupreorganise-desc
 * MediaWiki:pagetriage-tags-cleanupreorganise-desc

Too long - in progress

 * MediaWiki:pagetriage-tags-verylong-desc
 * MediaWiki:pagetriage-tags-condense-label

Science too complicated - done

 * MediaWiki:pagetriage-tags-technical-desc
 * MediaWiki:pagetriage-tags-technical-desc

image copyright issues

 * MediaWiki:pagetriage-tags-nonfree-desc

POV

 * MediaWiki:pagetriage-tags-pov-desc
 * MediaWiki:pagetriage-tags-unbalanced-desc

Template:Stub text

 * MediaWiki:pagetriage-tags-stub-label
 * Only a few languages, check again about LocalisationUpdate

NeedsImage
Add icon, does not contain text

Image essential

 * MediaWiki:Mobile-frontend-photo-upload

Multiple issues - parameter error detected

 * mediawiki:Cleanup-problems-are

Tidy citations - not working

 * MediaWiki:pagetriage-tags-citationstyle-desc
 * MediaWiki:pagetriage-tags-refimprove-desc
 * MediaWiki:
 * -For references that need a cleanup
 * The reference section needs improving.
 * The reference section may use bare URLs.
 * The reference section may use bare URLs.

Spelling or grammar

 * MediaWiki:pagetriage-tags-copyedit-desc
 * MediaWiki:pagetriage-tags-cleanupreorganise-desc

Accuracy - currently used by POV
MediaWiki:pagetriage-tags-disputed-desc

Editorial guidelines - barely started

 * MediaWiki:Guidelines-editorial
 * Editorial guidelines not met
 * Editorial guidelines not met

Rewrite for editorial guidelines

 * MediaWiki:Cleanup-tags-rewrite-desc


 * based on: MediaWiki:Pagetriage-tags-leadrewrite-desc


 * MediaWiki:pagetriage-tags-citationstyle-desc

Future use

 * MediaWiki:view-guidelines
 * MediaWiki:pagetriage-del-tags-cat-csd-label (Speedy deletion)
 * MediaWiki:pagetriage-del-tags-cat-csd-desc
 * MediaWiki:pagetriage-page-status-delete
 * MediaWiki:pagetriage-del-tags-articlefordeletion-label
 * (Articles for deletion)

References in visual editor

 * MediaWiki:citoid-referencecontextitem-convert-button Convert (already exists)
 * MediaWiki:Citoid-referencecontextitem-convert-message

What was the bug?
Curious what the outstanding bug was since I don't have a record of it. I remember a series of awkward bugs on this but thought the last had been resolved so I'm curious. The categorizing by year was deliberate. Not a big issue to remove though. notjusttired (talk) 20:26, August 22, 2019 (EDT)
 * The bug was that, on every page with a "Cleanup" message, there was printed underneath the infobox.  This was not wikitext, but HTML visible to the reader.  You probably noticed this one.  Fixing this bug does not affect the categorizing by year.  None of the categories have changed as a result of fixing this bug.  There's still another bug left in the Cleanup template, but that can wait for another day.  Hope this clarifies.
 * Pyrrhus (talk) 00:07, August 23, 2019 (EDT)
 * That bug was a nightmare. I thought I might have fixed it but wasn't sure. Thanks notjusttired (talk) 06:10, August 23, 2019 (EDT)

Remove categories based on cleanup date? -- Pyrrhus (talk) 18:51, July 12, 2019 (EDT)
Does anyone have an objection if I update this template to only add cleanup articles to one category: Category:All articles needing cleanup? It’s annoying to maintain separate categories based on date, such as Category:All articles needing cleanup from November 2015 and Category:Cleanup tagged articles with a reason field from November 2015. Pyrrhus (talk) 18:51, July 12, 2019 (EDT)
 * So no objections on removing the categories based on date?
 * Pyrrhus (talk) 22:12, July 14, 2019 (EDT)


 * No objections from me. Kmdenmark (talk) 15:12, July 24, 2019 (EDT)


 * I would like to move to having them by year ago - less to maintain but also we can quickly spot important pages that have been marked for cleanup since 2015. I don't understand the difference between and  - but the last one has more pages in it. notjusttired (talk) 18:56, July 24, 2019 (EDT)

Add subcategories to cleanup category based on reason
I'm wondering about using subcategories for different reasons, with all still in the original category. I'm going to create a series of subtemplates anyway that can be picked to automatically fill out a particular reason (which people can add to). Suggested reasons listed below. notjusttired (talk) 19:49, July 13, 2019 (EDT)
 * Sounds interesting. What is the benefit of doing this?
 * Pyrrhus (talk) 23:33, July 19, 2019 (EDT)
 * Benefits would be that you could choose just to type of cleanup rather than facing hundreds of pages to choose from (although that list would be there too). So if you don't feel like doing references, you could do a bias/neutrality edit and just rephrase things. Or you could just sort out the images. Or just spelling. Also if using the visual editor you can make for cleanup by picking the Cleanup/spelling, Cleanup/bias etc from the menu instead of going your reason.

With categories, I think the categories for cleanup reason should not include a date, which would avoid the extra work of creating / deleting categories every year. I might try out creating one first, to get the coding right. notjusttired (talk) 18:58, July 24, 2019 (EDT)notjusttired (talk) 17:53, July 24, 2019 (EDT)
 * Sounds good. Thanks for doing it. Kmdenmark (talk) 14:05, August 1, 2019 (EDT)

The ReplaceText feature can be used to move existing articles into a new subcategory
 * accuracy - disputed
 * bias - promotional content, misleading or lacks neutrality disputed
 * citations needed
 * editorial - editorial guidelines not met
 * image copyright - no copyright information on image, or image may not be licensed for reuse
 * image essential
 * layout - poor or cluttered
 * multiple issues
 * spelling or grammar
 * rewrite (see Template:Cleanup-rewrite)
 * sources unreliable - may not meet science guidelines
 * tidy citations
 * too long
 * too technical

Short message tasks (labels)

 * accuracy is disputed
 * (Neutrality/POV - bias eg promotional content, misleading or lacks neutrality disputed)
 * more citations needed/unsourced
 * image copyright''' missing or images may not be licensed for reuse
 * image essential'''
 * layout''' is poor or article is cluttered
 * multiple issues
 * spelling or grammar
 * rewrite (quality standards)
 * sources unscientific
 * / (tidy citations) citation style/Bare URLs
 * too long
 * too technical
 * too technical

Clean up message change
Instead of just linking to the quality standards (MOS) I would like to link to both the editorial and science guidelines in the message as well. The are new and some existing editors won't have seen them. It will also make them much easier to find. notjusttired (talk) 19:49, July 13, 2019 (EDT)
 * Sounds good. We could as well just link to Category:MEpedia guidelines.
 * Pyrrhus (talk) 23:33, July 19, 2019 (EDT)